
Yes, in most cases. US-listed rare earth companies such as MP Materials and funds such as REMX can be held in an IRA at almost every provider. The two exceptions to watch are physical metals, which you generally can’t hold in an IRA, and foreign or over-the-counter shares, where it depends on your provider’s rules.
Here’s what’s allowed, what isn’t, and the details that catch people out.
What you can and can’t hold
| Investment | Allowed in an IRA? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| US-listed rare earth stocks (MP, UUUU, USAR) | Yes, at almost all providers | Bought like any other stock |
| US-listed ETFs (REMX, SETM, LIT) | Yes, at almost all providers | Often the simplest option |
| Foreign shares (Lynas on the ASX, Iluka) | Depends on the provider | Many restrict international trading in retirement accounts |
| US OTC listings (LYSCF, LYSDY) | Depends on the provider | Some allow them, some block OTC trades in IRAs |
| Physical rare earth metals | Generally no | Treated as a “collectible” under the tax code |
Why physical metals are out
Under section 408(m) of the Internal Revenue Code, an IRA that buys a “collectible” is treated as if you had withdrawn that money. The definition of collectible includes any metal, with narrow exceptions for certain gold, silver, platinum and palladium coins and bullion held by an approved trustee. Rare earth metals aren’t on the exception list. Buying them in an IRA would be treated as a taxable distribution, and if you’re under 59½ you could also owe the 10% early-withdrawal penalty.
That’s rarely a practical loss: there’s no simple, liquid retail market for physical rare earths anyway.
How to buy rare earth stocks in an IRA, step by step
- Check your contribution room. For 2026, the IRS limit is $7,500 a year across all your traditional and Roth IRAs, plus a $1,100 catch-up if you’re 50 or older.
- Confirm what your provider allows. Search its help pages for “foreign securities”, “international trading” and “OTC” in IRAs. If you want Lynas or other ASX names, this decides whether you can buy them directly.
- Choose your vehicle. A US-listed ETF is the easiest IRA holding. Individual US stocks come next. Foreign or OTC shares only if your provider permits them.
- Use a limit order for smaller or volatile stocks so you control the price you pay.
- Keep the position small. A retirement account is where volatility can do the most long-term damage if a single theme dominates it.
Details that catch people out
Traditional or Roth? In a Roth IRA, qualifying withdrawals are tax-free, so large gains are never taxed. The other side: losses in an IRA can’t be deducted, and a volatile position that falls a long way also shrinks a limited contribution allowance you can’t easily rebuild.
Foreign dividends. If a foreign company pays dividends, its home country may withhold tax. In a taxable account you can often claim a foreign tax credit; inside an IRA you generally can’t, so that withheld tax is lost. Many rare earth companies pay little or nothing in dividends, so this matters more for diversified miners than for producers like Lynas.
No tax-loss harvesting. Because gains and losses inside an IRA aren’t reported year by year, you can’t use a falling rare earth stock to offset taxable gains elsewhere.
Concentration in a fund you already own. If your IRA holds a broad materials or mining fund, you may already own some rare earth names. Check before adding more.
Which route is simplest?
For most people, a single US-listed ETF is the easiest way to hold the theme in an IRA: no foreign trading rules, no OTC restrictions, and diversification across many companies. If you prefer individual stocks, US-listed names avoid most complications. We compare the funds in our guide to the best rare earth ETFs, the main US-listed company in Is MP Materials a good investment?, and brokers in our best brokerage guide.
Sources
- IRS: Investments in collectibles in individually directed accounts (IRC 408(m))
- InvestmentNews: IRS 2026 IRA and 401(k) contribution limits
This article is general information, not tax or investment advice. Tax rules depend on your situation; check with your IRA provider or a tax professional before acting.
