Energy Fuels vs MP Materials: Two US Rare Earth Stocks, Two Very Different Businesses

Open-pit mine beside an industrial processing mill

Last updated: November 1, 2026, to reflect Energy Fuels’ completed acquisition of Australian Strategic Materials and its new heavy rare earth plant.

MP Materials and Energy Fuels are the two US-listed companies that separate rare earths on American soil today, which is why they’re so often compared. But they’re built very differently. MP Materials is a rare earth company: it mines its own ore, started separating NdPr oxide in 2023, ramped up sharply since, and is now making magnets. Energy Fuels is mainly a uranium company with a smaller, newer rare earth business that buys in its feedstock and is betting on a large expansion later this decade.

Which one fits a portfolio depends on what you want to own. Here’s how they compare on the facts.

Side by side

MP MaterialsEnergy Fuels
ListingNYSE: MPNYSE American: UUUU (also TSX: EFR)
Main businessRare earths: mining, separation, metal and magnetsUranium, with rare earths, mineral sands and vanadium
Where rare earths come fromIts own Mountain Pass mine, CaliforniaMonazite bought from other producers, plus future supply from mineral sands projects in Australia, Madagascar and Brazil
Rare earth processingMountain Pass separation; metal and magnets at Fort Worth, TexasWhite Mesa Mill, Utah; metals and alloy plant in South Korea, acquired with Australian Strategic Materials in August 2026
NdPr output2,599 t in 2025Phase 1 circuit designed for about 850–1,000 t a year
Heavy rare earthsSeparation being commissioned in 2026Pilot production so far; commercial dysprosium and terbium circuits under construction since July 2026, due to be commissioned in Q4 2027
Government linksDoD shareholder, $110/kg NdPr price floor, magnet offtakeNo equivalent price floor
China’s export control listAdded June 22, 2026Not listed

Sources: company filings and results releases. Figures are the latest published at the time of writing.

How MP Materials makes its money

MP’s results rise and fall with NdPr. It mined about 50,700 tonnes of rare earth oxide in concentrate in 2025 and turned more of it into separated NdPr oxide, producing 2,599 tonnes, double the year before. Since October 2025, a ten-year agreement with the US Department of Defense tops up its income whenever the NdPr market price is below $110 per kilogram. Next comes magnets: deliveries to General Motors and Apple, and a large new magnet plant in Texas targeted for commissioning in 2028.

That gives MP a clear, single story. The flip side is concentration: one mine, one main product and a business plan closely tied to US government support. We dig into it in Is MP Materials a good investment?

How Energy Fuels makes its money

Energy Fuels’ biggest business today is uranium. Its White Mesa Mill in Utah, the only conventional uranium mill operating in the US, produced more than one million pounds of uranium concentrate in 2025. The same mill also processes monazite, a mineral sand that contains both uranium and rare earths, which is how the company got into rare earth separation.

Its rare earth plan has three layers:

  • Now: a Phase 1 separation circuit at White Mesa, designed to make roughly 850–1,000 tonnes of NdPr a year from purchased monazite, plus pilot-scale production of heavy rare earths such as dysprosium. A commercial heavy rare earth expansion, estimated at about $104 million, has been under construction since July 2026.
  • Feedstock of its own: the Donald project in Australia (where it is earning a 49% stake and gets all the rare earth output), Vara Mada in Madagascar and Bahia in Brazil. Management has said Donald could start supplying White Mesa in late 2027 or early 2028.
  • Scale-up: a planned Phase 2 expansion that would lift White Mesa to about 6,294 tonnes a year of NdPr, plus 80 tonnes of terbium and 288 tonnes of dysprosium oxide, targeted for 2029 and subject to permits and funding.

To fund this, Energy Fuels raised $700 million through convertible notes in October 2025. In January 2026 it agreed to buy Australian Strategic Materials, and the takeover was completed in August 2026. That adds a metals and alloy plant in South Korea, with installed capacity of 1,300 tonnes a year of neodymium-iron-boron alloy, and the permitted Dubbo rare earths project in Australia.

The real differences

Pure play or diversified. MP gives you rare earths and little else. Energy Fuels gives you uranium first, with rare earths as a growing option. If uranium prices fall, Energy Fuels feels it; MP doesn’t.

Owned ore or bought feedstock. MP controls its supply at Mountain Pass. Energy Fuels currently depends on buying monazite until its own mineral sands projects start up, which makes its rare earth margins more exposed to feedstock prices and availability.

Today versus later. MP’s rare earth business is already at scale. Most of Energy Fuels’ rare earth value depends on projects that haven’t been built yet.

Policy. MP has a government price floor and the DoD as shareholder, but is also on China’s export control list. Energy Fuels has neither the floor nor the listing.

Who each one tends to suit

  • MP Materials fits investors who want direct exposure to US rare earth production and magnets, and who accept single-site and policy risk.
  • Energy Fuels fits investors comfortable with uranium as the core business, who see rare earths as an option that could grow into something large if the expansion plans are delivered.

Neither is a safe holding, and both can move sharply on headlines. If you want to compare MP with the biggest producer outside the US, see MP Materials vs Lynas Rare Earths. And if choosing between individual companies feels like too much, a fund may suit you better, as explained in rare earth stocks vs ETFs.

Sources

Scroll to Top